The X-Axis – 6 March 2011
After last week’s deluge of X-Men titles, this week Marvel change tack to ship three Wolverine titles. Yes, okay, one of them is Daken. But still…
Avengers Academy #10 – Well, that’s odd. The cover of this issue is the Academy trainees and the cast of New Avengers teaming up to fight magic thingies, with a big “Magic 101” banner over the top. And the interior… features Hazmat spending a day off with Leech, and Speedball delivering a lesson about how he feels about the Stamford disaster from Civil War. And that’s a perfectly good story, albeit of a rather deck-clearing sort. It addresses the obvious question of why Hazmat doesn’t just get her hugely inconvenient powers removed for good, using one of the various well-established techniques available in the Marvel Universe for such endeavours. And it continues the detoxification of Speedball, who’s going to require a lot of that sort of thing before he’ll be anything other than the poster child for really inane ideas, but points for trying. What it doesn’t do… is bear the slightest resemblance to the story advertised on the cover. Strange choice.
Daken: Dark Wolverine #6 – This is billed as “Empire, Act 2, part 3 of 4”. Last month I pointed out that part 1, where Daken visited the Fantastic Four, seemed to be a completely unrelated story. Well, that point becomes a little clearer here, as a macguffin from that issue turns out to be important here, though I’d still query whether it’s really a single arc. And part 4, it turns out, doubles as the first part of “Collision”, a crossover with X-23. That’s a curious sort of four-part story, and no mistake.
Anyhow, Daken’s still in Madripoor, where he claims to be helping out Tyger Tiger in taking down a ring of evil bankers. Can you guess where this is going? Well, if you’ve been reading the series thus far, then yes, you’ve probably figured out that Daken screws everyone in order to pursue his own secret agenda. Incidentally, Tyger Tiger is the current ruler of Madripoor and not, as the recap page claims, a vigilante. That’s a very strange error, because it’s a central plot point.
This series has been bogged down in “What’s Daken up to?” stories for some time, and in a sense it’s still doing more or less the same mystery. Is Daken just an insane nihilist, or is he deliberately trying to echo parts of Wolverine’s past life, or does he have some more concrete idea in mind? It’s not necessarily a bad set-up. My major problems with earlier arcs were that Daken didn’t really seem to do anything in particular, making his motives largely academic; and that the book was pretty much devoid of sympathetic characters, given that Daken himself evidently wasn’t going to fill that role. With this arc, though, Daken’s plans finally start to develop a sense of scale; and the writers seem to be positioning Tyger Tiger to fill the gap where the book’s heart ought to be. As a result, it’s one of the stronger Daken arcs. And Giuseppe Camuncoli’s art remains a strength for the book – it’s nice to see somebody putting some thought into the range of locations that Madripoor theoretically always provided, instead of sticking the familiar back streets.
The Intrepids #1 – A new series from Image, written by Kurtis J Wiebe and drawn by Scott Kowalchuk. It’s a sort of retro team book, dumping the superhero trappings in favour of a mad scientist vibe. A scientific genius called Dante has taken in a group of abandoned kids, fitted them out with super powers (sorry, “augmentations”), and sent them to battle mad scientists who do things like make cyborg bears. It’s a familiar set-up – mentor and team of young wards – and while it’s got the Silver Age aspects of, well, cyborg bears, it’s mostly played straight. I kept expecting it to be a little more over the top, but it’s not really trying for that; ultimately, it felt more like a premise that would make for a pretty good Saturday morning cartoon. It’s a good solid book with well-defined characters and the potential for long-term development; and while it’s not tremendously original, it does find a way of doing the classic Silver Age team book dynamic while removing the superhero trappings. It’s missing the sort of stand-out moment that would really grab the attention, but there’s certainly promise here.
Joe the Barbarian #8 – The thing about serialisation is that the first issue of this series came out over a year ago. Grant Morrison’s stories often work by seeding clues in the early issues that pay off later on, and I’m sure that if I sat down and read the whole thing as a graphic novel, it would come together much better. I’ll try and find the time to do that. But reading it in single issues? The art’s lovely, but the ending is pretty much what you were probably expecting all along, and I can’t honestly say I have a strong enough recollection of the earlier chapters for the details to really work. It comes across as a bit of an anticlimax. Still, I suspect it’ll work better read in one go…
Wolverine/Hercules: Myths, Monsters & Mutants #1 – A four-issue miniseries by Frank Tieri and Juan Santacruz. It’s a belated sequel to a Hercules miniseries that Tieri wrote in 2005, now co-starring a character who has no connection to Herc whatsoever. To be fair, that Hercules mini was quite decent, and Tieri immediately sets about defining some common ground between the characters that gives him something to work with, specifically the fact that they’re going to outlive pretty much everyone they know. There’s even a flashback to their first meeting, which is staggeringly obscure continuity – it’s from a six-page back-up strip in Marvel Treasury Edition #26.
As a throwaway caption explains, this is set “Years ago” – I can’t help wondering if that’s because somebody belatedly noticed that the villain, Matsuo Tsurayaba, was already killed off in last year’s Psylocke mini. Fortunately, that’s not really a major problem, because it looks like the real focus of this mini is basically going to be Hercules and Wolverine teaming up to fight mythical stuff (and occasionally pausing to bemoan the inevitable passing of all else that lives). It’s more a parade of cool stuff than an actual story – this issue opens with a seemingly irrelevant flashback to a giant Nazi robot attacking Paris, after all – but it’s good natured stuff and perfectly enjoyable. The art’s a bit patchy but generally pretty decent. The real question is whether there can possibly be enough demand to support yet another Wolverine mini, but the book is fine.
Wolverine: The Best There Is #4 – Well, it’s getting better. Which is to say, this issue is neither unintelligible nor incoherent. Winsor wants to experiment on Wolverine’s healing factor in order to learn about… well, ostensibly to develop a cure for his son, though that might not be the real reason after all. Cue an issue of people torturing Wolverine and discussions about how his healing factor works. Like several writers of recent years, Charlie Huston seems understandably vexed by the way Wolverine’s healing powers have become more and more exaggerated over the years, and he’s hunting for a solution. His explanation – which has the merit of simplicity, at least – is essentially that the more it gets used, the stronger it gets. As before, there’s a halfway interesting idea in there, but it isn’t developing into much of a story. It’s hard to avoid the feeling that Huston has started off with a remit to write a mature readers Wolverine comic and worked backwards from there, resulting in a story which is literally just a string of healing factor stunts in a row.
X-Factor #216 – Spider-Man guest stars. Or rather, J Jonah Jameson does, as he shows up in the traditional role of giving X-Factor their mission and nudging them in the direction of the plot. From the look of it, this is where we get back to the subplot set up a few months ago, about the woman who’d been programmed with false memories and got Monet to erase them. There’s a nice little mystery being set up there. There’s also a good subplot scene with Layla and Rahne; it’s not so much Layla’s ultimatum to Rahne that’s interesting as the fact that she’s uncharacteristically taking such an active role at all. I’m not quite convinced that the guest stars add much to the book beyond some window dressing to accompany the exposition, but Peter David writes them entertainingly enough that I’m willing to let it slide. (And the Black Cat’s on the cover of the next issue, so to be fair, he might not be finished with the Spider-Man characters just yet.) Always a reliable book.
The “years ago” caption probably has more to do with the fact that the past year has seen Herc “dead”, overpowered and now depowered (his status quo in his new ongoing as a street-level vigilante); and before that he was travelling with his deaged dad and Amadeus Cho.
Meaning if you want a simple, unattached status quo for Herc, you need to rewind to pre-WWHulk.
Joe the Barbarian seems to be one of those cases where the cult of the writer – and in particular, the cult of Morrison, which has spent the last umpteen years giddily insisting that there are secret knots, formulas and connections in all of Morrison’s stuff – really works against the comic, since apparently a bunch of Morrison fanatics have been expecting secret sigils or fiction suits or whatever the Morrisonwank of the day happens to be, and were tricked into buying a some excellent Sean Murphy art instead. Anyway, it’s been a perfectly enjoyable fantasy comic drawn by an amazing artist, and I hope to see more of him soon.
Paul,
Just wanted to alert you in case you missed it – this week’s 5 Ronin #1 starred Wolverine as penned by Peter Milligan. A quirky idea with nice art, albeit retreading the old ground of Lone Wolf and Cub on the surface.
5 Ronin is weekly and it looks like each issue tackles a different character reimagined for feudal Japan – #2 stars the Hulk.
Filed under the”experimental” wing of the Marvel Universe.
@Moose n Squirrel: Hear Hear. Check out Sean Murphy on Hellblazer: City of Demons mini if you haven’t already. Lovely stuff.
I always thought there was a lot of potential in the ongoing revenge of Wolvie on Matsuo, sadly the Psylocke mini looked awful so I skipped it.
So… The Intrepids is The Umbrella Academy then?
Disapointed that X-Factor has Jonah as a mutant-hater – my understanding of him has always been that once you got past his irrational hatred of Spider-Man and his gruff exterior, he was a pretty liberal guy. I remember an X-Men story where he threw a representative of Graydon Creed out of his office.
(Then again, this may be accurate to the current setup – I get the UK reprints, where JJJ has just become mayor, and he does seem to be more intolerant of everything than he used to be — even denouncing his own former employees as “the liberal media”.)
PAD’s excuse for that JJJ scene: http://comicboards.com/php/show.php?rpy=xmb-2011030317531415
hmmm, didn’t JJJ actually help the X-Men with something? aside from the Graydon Creed supporter thing mentioned above, I remember some point in the mid to late 90’s JJJ feeding the X-Men information about something.
was it Bastion?
Jameson’s attitude didn’t really bother me because, while he was mouting off, he was also coming to X-Factor for help; something an anti-mutant bigot wouldn’t do. I can see him acting the way he did because:
1) Jameson’s predisposed to dislike everyone.
2) With the exception of his son, Jameson berates even people he DOES like (look at pretty much any exchange between JJJ and his best friend, Robbie Robertson).
3) Jameson’s refusal to help anti-mutant groups in the past just proves that he doesn’t HATE mutants, not that he LIKES them. Believing that a group of people shouldn’t be oppressed isn’t the same as embracing them on a personal level.
Throw it all together and it’d be weird if Jameson DIDN’T act like a jerk. Because, well, he’s a jerk.
For what it’s worth, JJJ’s OHOTMU entry back in the eighties specifically noted that “he doesn’t share the widespread prejudice against mutants”.
The only thing I can think of concerning the Avengers Academy cover is that it’s a personal decision by Rachel Pinnelas, the new assistant editor of the book. I worked at Marvel for a bit alongside Rachel, and she was a massive Dr. Strange fan, often joking that she had a crush on him. I imagine that she probably read the script, realized it was the first comic she’d be editing to contain an appearance by Dr. Strange and commissioned a cover with that as the focus. This is all just speculation though.
minus the weird “Magic 101” banner, the rest of the cover sort of makes sense, as several Avengers make cameo appearances teaching various classes. Its the banner that’s the odd thing, not the cover itself.
Dear Paul,
I probably realize you’re an lifelong x fan, and I love reading your criticism, but your focus on X books is SO limiting. While I appreciate your column as a tried and true comic book critic (and comic dealer), I hope you’ll someday eschew the emphasis on x books and cover the wider path of comics. I’ve read SO much critical writing on comics, i believe your stuff to be far above the subject you limit yourself to (comic book wise). But since i’m not one to tell MY customers what to read and enjoy, I’ll just end this with saying I’ll always check in once a week to see what you’re up to. Thanks to you for your time and efforts to make this a better art form.
Vernon Wiley
The Comix Gallery
Wilmette Illinois, USA
Hey Paul, I was trying to find some of your old X-Axis writings and found that the site was down.
Any chance you’ve got those archived somewhere? I was really wanting to read over the old reviews of The Twelve story arc and go over your notes about what the story was originally supposed to be.
You can grab a copy of the old X-axis site here: http://www.megaupload.com/?d=PV7N2DYF
Paul, you really ought to put a link to that archive on the front page or something.
Also, is the old yahoo group that you used to post them at still up?
Vernon,
As a long-time reader of Paul’s work, his column has undergone many mutations through the years (no pun intended), depending on his time and/or fancy.
First, it was all the X-books, then he added in a full review of something else that struck his fancy (usually a new series or “important” issue of something), then he threw in capsule reviews of *everything* he read (I really miss those! Bring them back!!), then scaled back to only focus on completed storylines, and now it seems he’s back to all of the X-books plus whatever else.
This is all to say that, while the focus on X probably isn’t going anywhere, there’s enough other stuff to interest those of us who don’t read those books.
For further samples of Paul’s non-X work, check out his columns for http://www.ninthart.com, the archives of which I believe are still online.
Okay, that Ninth Art link was certainly NOT what I thought it was. Paul, Al, are the archives gone again?
Okay, sorry for the reply to my reply to my own post, but it’s http://www.ninthart.org. Lotsa great stuff there.