RSS Feed
Apr 14

The X-Axis – 11 April 2010

Posted on Wednesday, April 14, 2010 by Paul in x-axis

Ridiculously late, I know, but then I didn’t actually get a chance to read any of these books until yesterday.  Such is the fate of those who rely on a combination of Diamond and the postal service.

Batman & Robin #11 – “The Return of Bruce Wayne begins here!”, says the cover, which is an odd thing to put on the second part of a storyline, but that’s DC for you.  In this issue, the new Batman continues to explore the underground bits of Wayne Manor, while Robin teams up with a bloke in a mask to fight some baddies.  Is the bloke in the mask Bruce Wayne?  Probably not, because that’d be a bit obvious.  As I feared, now that we’re getting to the obligatory mechanics of returning to the traditional Batman set-up, this really isn’t anything particularly special.  Part of the problem, I suspect, is that we’re now getting into the territory of established villains like Damian’s mother wandering about, and she’s a character I neither know nor care about.  And neither knowing nor caring about major characters is… an issue.  It’s fine, it’s well paced, it’s efficiently handled, it just doesn’t grab me.

Cinderella: From Fabletown With Love #6 – The concluding part of the miniseries.  I’m not sure this has really worked.  Partly, that’s because three Fables titles a month is stretching it, particularly when the third one is lagging so far behind in continuity that it’s evidently been tied up in development for an age.  But mainly it’s because the basic conceit of Cinderella as a Bond-style spy isn’t sustained effectively for the whole series.  The problem here is that they’ve ended up doing a story about a spy for the Fables universe, but that character doesn’t have a great deal to do with Cinderella, and so when they wheel out bits of Cinderella’s background, it feels rather forced.  And that means that the “characters from fables in the modern world” routine has been done better by the parent title.  Shawn McManus’ art is excellent, and the story itself is acceptable, but it doesn’t quite pull off the admittedly tricky task of blending these two ideas.

Deadpool & Cable #25 – Or just Cable #25, if you go by the indicia.  It goes without saying that Deadpool is overexposed to the point of self-parody these days, and Marvel seem to be trying to make a virtue of necessity by turning that into a joke in its own right.  So here’s Deadpool to bid farewell to a series he never really appeared in.  That said, while this is notionally the final issue of Cable, it’s actually more of a coda to the Cable & Deadpool ongoing series that preceded it.  It’s a flashback story, with Deadpool helping Cable out during the “Messiah Complex” crossover and fending off the baddies while Cable gets to safety.  It’s quite a nice way of bringing the book full circle, but it’s not really enough of a story to justify an entire issue.  Deadpool is in full-blown fourth-wall mode here, by the way, not only lamenting the demise of their partnership but berating the fact that there’s still been no adequate explanation of why anyone regards Hope as important.  It’s almost as though they’ve belatedly figured out that they botched that one.  Best viewed as a one-shot wrapping up Cable and Deadpool’s erratic relationship, and it’s not really a storng enough story to recommend even on that level, but it’s not without its charm.

S.H.I.E.L.D. #1 – Jonathan Hickman and Dustin Weaver’s new series is thoroughly odd, recasting S.H.I.E.L.D. as a sort of Marvel Universe version of the Illuminati who’ve been secretly protecting the world from alien invasions and such like all the way down the centuries.  The framing story is set in the fifties; it’s about a guy called Leonid being recruited into the organisation.  But much of the issue is given over to flashbacks as diverse as Imhotep fighting the Brood and Leonardo da Vinci taking on Galactus.  While it’s certainly a Marvel Universe title in the sense that Marvel’s own mythology is deeply embedded into it, it’s not a superhero book in any normal sense.  Hickman’s indie work has generally been more eccentric than his relatively conventional Marvel books, but here he seems to be going off the deep end into something genuinely odd.  At the same time, it also has the best feature of his Fantastic Four stories, which is his willingness to take a thoroughly insane concept and run with it.  It’s too early to judge it as a story, but as a set-up issue establishing a truly demented premise, it works.  Admittedly, my sense of intrigue is somewhat undermined by the fact that I can’t imagine something like this lasting a year in the current market.  But presumably all involved are sufficiently alive to the commercial realities that they’ve got a good self-contained story lined up for the first few issues.  On the principle that “it’s bound to get cancelled” risks being a self-fulfilling prophecy, I’m going to stick with this one for a bit.

Spider-Man: Fever #1 – Artist Brendan McCarthy writes and draws a three-issue miniseries for the Marvel Knights imprint.  Despite the title, in spirit it’s more of a Dr Strange story with Spider-Man as a guest star.  Weird magical stuff escapes from a weird insect dimension and steals Spider-Man’s soul; it’s Dr Strange to the rescue.  The story is functional, but that’s not really the point.  This is McCarthy paying homage to Silver Age Steve Ditko by teaming up his two best known creations and going to town on the psychedelic landscapes in the same way that Ditko did.  It’s incredibly stagey at points – some of Strange’s dialogue is downright stilted – but that’s probably deliberate.  Some comics really are just an excuse for the artist to go nuts, and some artists are interesting enough to make that a good enough reason to put out a comic.  And this is an example.

Turf #1 – We’re going to talk about this on the podcast this weekend, but this is the miniseries by Jonathan Ross and Tommy Lee Edwards.  Now, while Jonathan Ross may be unknown in America, he’s a major star in Britain (think a younger David Letterman and you’re on the right lines), and even though he’s a well known comics fan, he’s a very big name celebrity to actually write one.  And he seems to be serious about it, too – he’s been doing the publicity rounds to promote the book, and he never does the publicity rounds himself.  For American audiences, of course, it’s an Image miniseries by an unknown writer and a well-respected artist.

So.  Any good?  Actually, on the whole, yes, it is.  The high concept is a turf war in prohibition-era New York between gangsters, vampires and, um, aliens.  But it’s played mostly straight – or deadpan, if you prefer – as a historical drama, with a dash of knowing absurdity.  Needless to say, Edwards is good at that.  It’s got an unusually rounded moral attitude to prohibition (yes, it’s a stupid law, but you are supporting organised crime…), and the gangster vampires are a fun idea.  On the downside… it’s probably a bit too dense, it’s very wordy (even Mark Millar’s characteristically enthusiastic afterword suggests a Don McGregor influence), and the tone is uneven, with occasional lurches into B-movie that don’t quite sit with the rest of the story.  But yes, it’s really quite decent, and a lot better than I was expecting.

Uncanny X-Men #523 – Part two of “Messiah Complex”, and fortunately we’ve got Terry and Rachel Dodson on art for this arc.  So not only is there brightly-coloured fighting, but it’s pretty and the characters are alive.  It’s a pretty good issue, too.  Part one set up the basic formula of the bad guys chasing Cable and Hope.  Fraction has fun with that here, as Hope gets used to a pre-apocalyptic society for a change, albeit one where everyone’s still shooting at her.  But he also introduces the second strand of the story, which is that all the dubious decisions Scott’s taken as leader of the X-Men over the last few years are evidently going to come home to roost.  X-Force have just been exposed, and the cuddly members of the group are thoroughly disconcerted.  Of course, they can’t exactly walk out now, what with the baddies trying to kill Hope… so they’re stuck with Scott for now.  And all this leads me to think that maybe recent commenters were right in suggesting that Scott’s the one in line for the chop here.  The build to this point has been decidedly erratic, but I’m still interested to see where it’s all heading, so job done, I suppose.

Wolverine: Weapon X #12 – The second part of “Tomorrow Dies Today”, in which timetravelling Deathlok cyborgs from the future come back to kill off leaders of a future rebellion – specifically, guest star Captain America.  Meanwhile, in the future, a band of rebels try to take down the Roxxon Corporation.  So… Terminator crossed with “Days of Futures Past”, then?  It’s fine, but it doesn’t have the inventiveness of the previous issue, and ends up getting a little more caught up in the cliches.

Bring on the comments

  1. So presumably Hickman is doing a better job of the “Marvel Universe version of the Illuminati” than Bendis managed?

    I still think there’s a conceptual issue there; why is there a secret group saving the world when the Avengers and Fantastic Four do it every day, and in front of the world’s media? What’s to be gained in the secret society angle? This is something Bendis never managed to answer, so I’d hope Hickman can.

  2. JD says:

    About the relief of Greg Land not drawing Uncanny X-Men during Second Coming : don’t worry, he’s drawing the X-Men Legacy issues !

  3. yeah! ho! wah! says:

    about uncanny x-men: did cable and hope really kill two police officers just to get some food from a super market? or did i miss something?

  4. Terence says:

    Re: Uncanny.
    I guess, if you’re sanctioning death squads, as Scott is, then you’r’e just another miserable Evil Mutant. Kill ‘im and move on.

  5. maxwell's hammer says:

    If that’s true about Land doing the ‘Legacy’ issues, it’ll be interesting to see how his ‘art’ effects Carey’s writing. I’ve always thought Fraction’s “Uncanny” would have read better with a different artist. Curious what happens when you change the writer-variable.

  6. Erik says:

    Talia Al Ghul is a pretty major character in the Batman universe. The daughter of his greatest foe and an off-again on-again love interest.

    I agree with you that using established villains takes away from the special-ness of B&R, but she’s a fairly major part of the characters’ history.

  7. Jerry Ray says:

    Yeah, it did very much look like Cable randomly killed people in a store for no very good reason. Not sure what was meant to have happened there.

  8. Jerry Ray says:

    Oh, and note to X-Force: murdering baddies in front of the members of the team from which your existence is supposed to be a secret is really not the best way to maintain the veil of secrecy…

  9. Valhallahan says:

    I haven’t read turf yet, but I picked it up along with American Vampire this week. Weird to have two books with 1920s vampires in one week.

  10. Suzene says:

    I can see Cyclops getting ousted from leadership after this reveal, but I don’t think he’s the one who’ll bet killed off — he was still around in that Second Coming freebie preview, wasn’t he?

  11. Entropest says:

    “Part two of “Messiah Complex””

    I’m sure you meant “Second Coming”, eh? ; )

  12. ZZZ says:

    When the previous installment of “Second Coming” ended with the X-Men teleporting in to attack the people chasing Cable and Hope, I thought “If this entire plotline is going to be Cable and Hope driving across the country with the X-Men trying to catch up to them instead of next issue starting with either them seeing the X-Men in the rearview mirror and pulling over or Nightcrawler or Majik teleporting in front of them and waving them down, they’ve officially lost me.”

    Well, the X-Men inexplicably did let Cable and Hope just drive off (apparently at such high speeds that they managed to make it to someplace where it was still dark out and rob a convenience store before the X-Men could finish having their argument) but they also met up with them by the end of the issue, so at least it looks like we’ll be spared a reprise of Cable and Bishop’s extended Roadrunner homage.

    All in all, though, it really reads like there are a couple of scenes missing, or at least out of order.

  13. arseface says:

    Law of diminishing returns: in the Messiah Complex storyline, the lone Predator X is treated as an unstoppable mutant-killing monster, held valiantly at bay by a team of X-Men and only killed by Wolverine going down his gullet. Not too long ago, Magneto struggled to stop one.

    In the last few weeks, however, Fantomex has killed one of off-camera and Deadpool casually killed another while cracking jokes. What a fall from grace – it reminds me of the spell last year when Galactus was getting killed or neutralised in what seemed like every other book.

  14. Daibhid Ceannaideach says:

    thekelvingreen: “I still think there’s a conceptual issue there; why is there a secret group saving the world when the Avengers and Fantastic Four do it every day, and in front of the world’s media? What’s to be gained in the secret society angle? This is something Bendis never managed to answer, so I’d hope Hickman can.”

    Well, in the modern era “the Shield” is S.H.I.E.L.D., so presumably has the same justification as S.H.I.E.L.D. has always had (in addition to apparently knowing The Destiny Of Humanity).

    There’s a subtle reference that I almost missed; the Asian branch of the Shield doesn’t have access to Imhotep’s magic shield, but another artifact: a spear. And ISTR that in that Nick Fury mini which revealed S.H.I.E.L.D. was secretly a division of HYDRA, HYDRA gets called “the Spear” at one point…

  15. yeah! ho! wah! says:

    “Well, the X-Men inexplicably did let Cable and Hope just drive off (apparently at such high speeds that they managed to make it to someplace where it was still dark out and rob a convenience store before the X-Men could finish having their argument)”

    yeah that confused me as well. also, cable is trying to reach the x-men, right? so why didnt he just stop the van?

  16. Paul C says:

    I found ‘S.H.I.E.L.D.’ to be a nice little read. That it probably will be cancelled sort of made me enjoy it all the extra as it will most likely be one of the few story arcs that will be told. Jonathan Hickman should be set for real big things in the future.

    It is rather depressing though, and it says something about the current state of Marvel, that there is an air of expectation that it will be a miracle if the book lasts longer than a year.

    Ummm, how in the blue hell did Jonathan Ross snag Tommy Lee Edwards? One is awesome and the other is far from it.

  17. He can probably afford to pay his regular page rate, is the likely answer / cynical answer / both.

    //\Oo/\\

  18. odessa steps magazine says:

    I can’t wait to find out what SHIELD stood for in Renaissance Italy.

    I think Cinderella is a better companion book to Fables these days than Jack, which I grew tired of quickly when it became apparently a straightforward S&S book with Jack Frost and his clockwork owl.

    I hope we can get a few minutes on the podcast this week to discuss the new Matt Smith era of DR WHO.

  19. maxwell's hammer says:

    Yeah, not sure what they were thinking writing Jack out of his own book. Jack Frost isn’t horrible, but its just not the same. To their credit, they’ve loaded the current arc up with just enough weirdness to keep it barely interesting.

  20. Justin says:

    Yeah, if I had to pick between Cinderella and Jack I’d pick Cinderella. That’s not to say Cinderella doesn’t have a lot of room for improvement, I just really don’t enjoy reading Jack. I like the fables-verse, so I still pick it up but I haven’t really enjoyed it since before the crossover. I actually like Frost more than Jack himself, but I ready for him to be done with this weird world he’s stuck on.

  21. Armagon says:

    I really liked Cable #25 as a coda to C&D. Damn I miss that comic.

Leave a Reply