Laura Kinney: Wolverine #1 annotations
As always, this post contains spoilers, and page numbers go by the digital edition.
LAURA KINNEY: WOLVERINE #1
“All the Places You Will Go”
Writer: Erica Schultz
Artist: Giada Belviso
Colour artist: Rachelle Rosenberg
Letterer: Cory Petit
Editor: Mark Basso
This is the first ongoing series with the title Laura Kinney: Wolverine, but Laura previously had ongoing titles under the name X-23 during 2010-12 and 2018-19, plus All-New Wolverine in 2016-18. Hence the legacy numbering of issue #69.
WOLVERINE:
Laura struggles to understand Kamala’s optimism or even Sophie’s ability to adjust to the fall of Krakoa. She refers here to “the few times I let them talk me into hanging out”. That doesn’t really fit with her arc in NYX, in which she starts hanging out with the rest of the cast in order to get allies against Mojo.
On learning that young Ivan has been abducted to Dubai, Laura’s back story naturally motivates her to address this tale of child exploitation. Much of this story involves her expecting all mutants to be on her side and humans to be against her, and being surprised when neither of those turns out to be true. Logically, the existence of mutant villains shouldn’t come as a massive surprise to her, but to be fair, Laura is still in the mutant nation mindset of Krakoa.
At least at first, Laura is deeply unimpressed by Polly; she seems to regard Polly’s decision to stay closeted during the Krakoan era as a moral failing and takes it as read that Polly will see it the same way. She also regards even willing performers at the Delta as being exploited. But by the end of the story she decides that Polly just has a more balanced view of mutants and humans.
Laura leaves it to Kamala and Sophie to arrange Ivan’s reunion with his sister, the implication being that she feels uncomfortable with handling this sort of emotional moment herself – she watches from nearby, so she clearly could have done it in person.
SUPPORTING CAST:
Kamala Khan and Sophie Cuckoo both appear at the start and end, mainly to play up the contrast with Laura. Laura is hanging out with them, but Sophie still has her telepathic powers, so we’re probably somewhere between NYX #2 and #4.
Ivan is a mutant with mood-altering sweat who’s been abducted to Dubai, and Emery is his sister, apparently a mutant but with no powers beyond an unusual appearance. Emery’s approach to getting help for Ivan, a little oddly, is to write a letter and hide it at the Treehouse, apparently in the hope that someone from the X-Men will find it. Remarkably, she turns out to be right. According to Emery’s letter, she and her brother are Moldovans; she says they were both abducted from there, but it’s not clear how she escaped (or maybe got dumped), or how she got to New York. They’re both new characters.
Polly is a Dubai-based mutant who can detect other mutants. Since she’s white and blonde, presumably she wasn’t born in Dubai. She runs Oasis, which she describes as a “safe place” for mutants, funded by a “benefactor” whom she doesn’t identify. Maybe we’ll come back to that in future issues. After the Madame is defeated, Polly invites her human trafficking victims to come to Oasis as well; she never actually said that Oasis was mutant-specific, just that it was safe for mutants.
According to Polly, she chose to live as a human and was reluctant to out herself by moving to Krakoa; consequently, she missed the whole thing. She regrets this, which motivates her to create Oasis. She’s still very uncomfortable with anything illicit and has an unnamed “cop friend” who she talks to. Much to Laura’s surprise, the cop turns out to be completely legitimate and although we never see Oasis, all signs are that Polly was telling the truth about it.
Elektra – as the second Daredevil – shows up at the end to tease issue #2.
VILLAINS:
The Madame is a mutant based in Dubai and dealing in trafficked mutants. She also has ties with the Delta Disco, which employs low-level mutants as entertainers; several characters claim that these mutants are there willingly, and even Laura seems prepared to accept that, although she still regards them as being exploited.
The Madame turns out to be Cybelle, a bit part character from Uncanny X-Men #211 who was one of the first mutants killed in the Mutant Massacre. We already knew that Cybelle had been resurrected on Krakoa; she appears in Hellions #1.
Cybelle doesn’t ascribe her motivation to the fall of Krakoa. Rather, she points out that Laura doesn’t even know her name, and says that she was “just another random mutant resurrected to fill up the island”. She claims that once she was resurrected she was determined never to be a victim again, and she sees the Massacre as having happened because “the heroes let it happen”. Basically, she doesn’t buy into mutant identity as an organising principle; all this does somewhat fit with the Morlocks being generally unhappy with Krakoa and wanting to go their own way.
An unnamed bouncer at the Delta Disco is also a mutant with size-changing and strength powers. He knows what the Madame is up to but doesn’t much care as long as he’s okay. He puts up an impressive fight against Laura, but she does attack him first, so it’s not entirely clear whether he’s actively involved in the Madame’s activities or just turning a blind eye to them.
MISCELLANEOUS:
Page 3. The narration is a straight recap of Laura’s established back story and the fall of Krakoa, at a very high level.
Page 5. The Treehouse was the X-Men’s New York headquarters during the Krakoan era. The plaque reading “Dedicated to those who paid the ultimate price to fight fascism” was added as a memorial in Invincible Iron Man #20.
“Hence the legacy numbering of issue #69.”
Nice. 🙂
Kind of surprised they didn’t use an established mutant as the bouncer. Are Tower and Delgado tied up elsewhere?
@Omar- that’s been an issue throughout Fall of X. In X-Factor, for example, none of the members of X-Term except an out-of-character Darkstar are established mutants.
I meant, “an issue throughout From the Ashes”.
The plot requires Laura to be surprised that the bouncer is a mutant, so an established character wouldn’t have worked.
This was… very basic. What even is the setup here? ‘Laura gets notes from a hidey-hole in a tree’ is apparently good enough at least for the first two issues. I’m not convinced.
Remember when all the mutants on Earth bar a very few exceptions were meant to have been forced through the gates by Professor X?
“Remember when all the mutants on Earth bar a very few exceptions were meant to have been forced through the gates by Professor X?”
To be fair, that lasted all of five seconds before being addressed extremely inconsistently across the line. We had random mutants being murdered by a serial killer, rounded up for experimentation, rounded up for deportation to Arakkoa, hiding in suburbia, being smuggled to safety by Alpha Flight… no one seemed able to agree upon how many mutants were left on Earth, how they escaped being forcibly moved through the gates, what would happen to the leftovers. They didn’t even enforce Orchis’ exponential punishment system to any degree.
So now that they’re just introducing more mutants willy-nilly in every series while still claiming that most of them went off with Krakoa to the White Hot Room, it’s hard to take it seriously. Rogue’s kids, Kitty’s kids, Scott’s rescues, new Morlocks, new terrorists, new celebrities, mutants who have been here all along like Polly and that doctor in Storm and Oskar and Granny Smite and Xyber…
At least the Krakoa era took pains to play with existing, long-overlooked characters.
On the other hand, Cybelle is a -deep- freaking cut of a character. And she’s a good reminder that most of the old-school Morlocks were in the sewers because they were pretty antisocial, unable, or unwilling to fit into normal society. And she’s so obscure, she’s basically a blank slate. (At first I thought she was one of the Tunnelers, I’d forgotten she was literally one of the first named victims of the Massacre and that she’d been brought back in Hellions).
(Hey, maybe we can reintroduce that big purple mole mutant who actually dug his way to alert the X-Men…)
And the final hand (I’m Jumbo Carnation, okay?) introducing Polly as a very Caucasian blonde woman in Dubai felt kind of tonedeaf when the opportunity existed to create a character more appropriate to the region and culture. How about a privileged Muslim woman with ties to the royal family who uses her money and connections to keep mutants safe? There have been SO FEW Arabic mutants of note…
(And “power to detect other mutants” is the sort of thing one probably keeps tightly under wraps lest they be kidnapped and turned into a tool of the oppresser…)
Not sure why people have a problem with the sudden introduction of new mutants in the X-books at this point in time. Seems to me that it is sort of the line’s thing, and has been for decades.
Is it because it implies that the difficulty of access to most minor and background characters who are now implicitly in other dimension in Krakoa is not a deal breaker? I suppose that is a legitimate emotional response, but we probably should accept that the X-books will continue to be published without really pursuing a definitive resolution any time soon.
[…] KINNEY: WOLVERINE #1. (Annotations here.) I thought this was fairly bland on a first reading, but it grew on me as I was re-reading it for […]