X-Men #8 annotations
As always, this post contains spoilers, and page numbers go by the digital edition.
X-MEN vol 7 #8
“Raid on Graymalkin, part 1”
Writer: Jed MacKay
Penciller: Ryan Stegman
Inkers: JP Mayer, Livesay & Ryan Stegman
Colourist: Marte Gracia
Letterer: Clayton Cowles
Editor: Tom Brevoort
This is officially the first part of the “Raid on Graymalkin” crossover which runs between X-Men #8-9 and Uncanny X-Men #7-8. In practice, though, the story really began with Beast being abducted in the previous issue; this issue confirms that he was taken to Graymalkin. Jubilee and Calico were abducted in last week’s Uncanny X-Men #6.
THE X-MEN (ALASKA)
The Beast hasn’t been treated as a team member thus far, but Cyclops calls him an X-Man here, and he introduces himself to Calico as an X-Man. So let’s go with that.
He’s been abducted to Graymalkin so that he can be extradited to Terra Verde. This refers back to the Krakoan-era X-Force series, where Beast took over the minds of the entire country; this was supposed to be part of the Beast’s corruption. In X-Force vol 6 #20 and Wolverine vol 7 #13, Terra Verde was freed and X-Force did a deal to keep the whole thing quiet for a fairly paltry one billion dollars. The whole story is and always was ridiculous, because it expects us to believe that the entire population of the country – who were aware that they were under mind control – decided to keep quiet about it for no good reason. But taken at face value, it was a crime against humanity, making the Beast a rare case where the Graymalkin authorities actually have a point.
Of course, the current Beast is a clone of the original based on memories from early 1980s continuity, who has no recollection of any of this. It’s a matter of interpretation whether you regard him as the same character at all. Let’s assume for present purposes that the Terra Verdans were offered something a lot more generous than the original X-Force/Wolverine story claimed – which would frankly be essential for the original story to work as written in any way – and that the fall of Krakoa has removed whatever that incentive was, leaving them free to go for revenge on the Beast.
Cyclops thinks of Hank as his brother, and is grateful to have the “real” Hank back again. With Jean off in space, Hank is the oldest friend he has. Psylocke points out that Scott is unusually emotional about Hank and worries about his judgment.
Cyclops instructs Magik not to use lethal force against the Graymalkin guards, but gives her purely pragmatic rather than moral reasons for doing so. Of course, he might just be going for the reasons that he thinks will carry most weight with her. She sets demons from Limbo on the guards, which is interesting, since Limbo has been controlled by Madelyne Pryor for several years now – does Madelyne know she’s still using the demons as a resource?
Psylocke, Temper and Kid Omega also join the attack on Graymalkin; the Juggernaut is apparently setting up for some further attack to come.
The X-Men have devices to jam the Graymalkin sensors, which Beast built from equipment that they seized from O*N*E in issue #3. Cyclops seems to be saying simply that they’ve adapted O*N*E’s own stealth technology from that issue, rather than implying that the O*N*E soldiers were directly linked to Graymalkin.
THE X-MEN (LOUISIANA)
Jubilee is in prison after being abducted last time. It’s still not clear what the reason was for her abduction, since picking off random X-Men seems a fairly surefire way of prompting precisely the sort of response we see here.
Calico introduces herself to Beast as an X-Man so, again, let’s go with that. (Although Jubilee suggests that she only counts as half an X-Man.) As in Uncanny X-Men, she seems baffled by anything outside her experience as a rich kid who was kept extremely sheltered by her abusive mother, and prison is entirely outside her frame of reference. She’s so oblivious to everything in the outside world that she surely can’t have been away from home for long. She still assumes that complete strangers will attach some significance to her being “of the Louden County Simon-Pinettes”.
According to Warden Ellis, Calico’s family are wealthy and politically connected, and are willing to buy her out of prison on the grounds that she isn’t a mutant. This is interesting on a number of levels. First, a possible reading of Uncanny X-Men is that Calico isn’t a mutant at all, and that it’s her horse Ember who has the powers. But Ellis identifies Calico as one of the “muties” she wants to talk to, so Ellis certainly seems to think that Calico is a mutant, despite being willing to release her for money. Did Graymalkin actually bother checking, though?
Moreover, who are the family members? In Uncanny X-Men #3, Calico claimed to have left home with Ember after her house mysteriously caught fire, which seemed like a decidedly incomplete explanation. Is Ellis just lying about Calico’s family being willing to buy her out? At any rate, she refuses the offer and declares that she’s a mutant.
Rogue, Wolverine, Jitter and Ransom show up at the end, although not their fellow cast members Gambit, Nightcrawler or Deathdream.
Rogue knocks out Blob with one touch but doesn’t take on his powers. The art is inconsistent but the idea seems to be that she’s touching him with her bare hands – she’s coloured on page 25 as wearing gloves, but page 24 has her without, and since you can see her fingernails on that page, presumably it’s correct.
SUPPORTING CAST
Xorn also shows up for the X-Men’s briefing scene. Thanks for coming, Xorn.
VILLAINS
The Graymalkin Prison has a meal hall, and at least a few other prisoners to eat in it. It’s rendered as a dungeon, which is weird, but maybe it’s a basement level. The food is terrible, but Jubilee suggests that it’s simply very cheap prison food rather than actively inedible.
Larry Trask and his Sentinel cyborgs from the Sentinels mini are mentioned, and are called for assistance, but don’t appear on panel in this issue.
Corina Ellis is much more straightforwardly (and one-dimensionally) evil in this issue than she was in Uncanny X-Men #5, where she had a degree of humanity. She’s openly arranging to “sell” Hank to Terra Verde for execution – although if she thinks this is the same Beast who committed crimes against humanity then her attitude towards him as an individual might be understandable. She’s openly contemptuous towards all her prisoners, though, and explicitly instructs punishment beatings for no real reason.
She tells President Lopez to his face that she thinks his real motivation is to have a show trial to distract from the consequences of his alliance with Roxxon – it’s not clear whether she thinks this is just a statement of the blindingly obvious or whether she’s taking the opportunity to show some disdain for him.
Captain Ezra again appears as simply a basically competent henchman lieutenant.
Scurvy appears briefly; Ellis tells him to “bring the trustees online”, but it’s not clear whether that involves giving orders or taking some more direct control of them. According to Psylocke, the “trustees” have been “turned … into things”, but it’s not clear what’s been done to them.
The Blob is the only one of the trustees to appear in this issue. He does seem willing to fight for the prison, but he only gets one line of dialogue before being knocked out by Rogue, so we don’t learn why.
President Lopez is a new character, and the current President of Terra Verde. He claims to be driven by the opportunity to avenge the Beast’s crimes against his people, and vigorously denies Ellis’s claim that he actually wants a show trial to distract from the politican consequences of an alliance with Roxxon (though he does confirm the Roxxon relationship). Terra Verde has been making a “generous contribution” to Graymalkin’s operating budget. Roxxon play no active part in this story, and seem to be mentioned mainly to avoid readers thinking that Terra Verde might kind of have a point about this Beast guy.
I get that Scott’s emotions are getting the better of him but it’s been shown that there are actual supervillains like Sebastian Shaw and Sarah Gaunt in Graymalkin. What’s he planing on doing with them once the X-Men shut down Graymalkin? Lock them in the basement? Make them pinky swear not to hurt any civilians and let them go?
It is an interesting question whether Calico or Ember is the one with powers.The preview for issue 7 is out and Rogue wonders how Ember undid his bridle- that suggests there’s something go on with Ember. As for whether Warden Ellis would know, Scurvy IS a telepath. But Calico believes that she’s a mutant. Although some telepaths can tell whether a superhuman is a mutant even if the superhuman doesn’t know. For example, in Spectacular Spider-Men. Elementary is confused about whether or not she’s a mutant and Phoebe is able to tell her that she’s not a mutant. However,. not all telepaths can do that.
“does Madelyne know she’s still using the demons as a resource?”
In X-Men 3, Scott threatens to call his wife if ONE goes after the X-Men. Scott says “wife” and not “Jean”, so I was wondering if he was using Exact Words and had Maddie on speed-dial. However, if this scene is a reference to that issue, you’d think MacKay would have referenced X-Men 3. Then again, Breevort has said Maddie will be appearing in One World Under Doom, so maybe Illyana’s control over the demons has something to do with Doom’s machinations. Or not.
“Larry Trask and his Sentinel cyborgs from the Sentinels mini are mentioned, and are called for assistance”
I think the Wolfpack Sentinels are the Dog-Sentinels Ellis was working on in Sentinels 2, but they were said to be Ellis’s project, not Trask’s.
“Scurvy appears briefly; Ellis tells him to “bring the trustees online”, but it’s not clear whether that involves giving orders or taking some more direct control of them.”
Yeah, are the trustees being controlled by control collars or is Scurvy controlling them with his powers? In Uncanny X-Men 6, the collars on the trustees looked like control collars but Blob had an evil grin on his face this issue, which might indicate brainwashing.
“Rogue knocks out Blob with one touch but doesn’t take on his powers.”
I assumed she DID takes his powers- she just didn’t become fat like he is. Of course, his fatness seems to be related to his strength, innvulnerability and immovability. I get that writers don’t want to scenes where Rogue’s powers change her body, wreck her costume and she winds up naked when the powers wear off like Claremont did. But the alternative should be just saying that Rogue’s costume is made of unstable molecules and can’t be damaged, not ignoring the physical changes that should come with her powers.
The schism between Scott and Rogue seems contrived. The preview for Uncanny X-Men 7 shows that Scott didn’t want Rogue’s team coming along because if too many mutants show up, it will be seen as an act of war. This is just ridiculous. Scott’s X-Men attacking a prison holding mutant supervillains like Sebastian Shaw with demons won’t be seen as an act of war but if Rogue and Wolverine join them it will be an act of war?!? Maybe the idea is that the PTSD/ R-LDS/ whatever Scott was experiencing at the end of X-Men 3 is affecting his judgement but there’s no evidence of it.
So how widely known is that the Beast is a clone? TBH, that doesn’t seem like the sort of thing that Team Greymalkin would automatically know. And even if it was common knowledge, I can totally see the Terra Verdeans choosing to ignore it for political reasons.
Also: if it turns out that the horse is the one with the powers, I *so* hope they get a visit from Major Mapleleaf and Thunder.
“Xorn also shows up for the X-Men’s briefing scene. Thanks for coming, Xorn.”
Ha !
I really hope MacKay has some sort of plan with including Xorn into the supporting cast, because we’re running on two decades of him showing up intermittently with widely inconsistent characterizations and agendas (to say nothing of his brother). Some clarification and streamlining of what the character is supposed to be at this stage would be quite welcome.
(Spurrier kinda tried, but Legion of X was way too busy a book to give them any room, and his own idiosyncrasies didn’t help much with making things much clearer.)
@JD- It doesn’t help that Xorn is allegedly the team’s healer but in practice whenever someone like Magneto needs to be healed, he’s unable to do it for some reason.
@Michael: It’s a little funny to read that sentence, considering Xorn’s history.
There’s a reasonable chance Magneto is going through this nano-Sentinels. Max can control iron, but he’s helpless against irony.
@Taibak Thanks, now I can’t help but think that Ember and Thunder will be the comics romance of 2025.
@Sam: You’re welcome.
Cyclops sure is getting cover-punched by super-powerful women a lot this month. I hope he doesn’t get a concussion.
Luckily, Cover Scott exists in a pocket dimension separate from actual 616.
[…] #8. (Annotations here.) Part 1 of the “Raid on Graymalkin” crossover with Uncanny X-Men, and while Warden Ellis […]